Skip to main content

Big Buck Blunders

Big Buck Blunders

Have you ever lost sleep over a tall-tined monster you had dead-to-rights moments before he hightailed out of your life? Brother, I have. Although we want to pout, the only constructive thing we can do is learn from our mistake so it doesn't happen again. Here are several big-time blunders that saved a big buck – and could save you from future heartache.

Clank Fizzle Pop

Brad Gaddis caught a giant whitetail on a trailcam that he thought could challenge the Oklahoma state record. So on a cold and rainy afternoon, Gaddis put on his new, high-dollar raincoat over an extra layer and clambered into his stand. But when he removed his binocular from his backpack, he discovered its harness was too tight to wear around his chest. So he sat the bino in his lap.

An hour later the 16-point buck presented an easy 20-yard shot. But when Gaddis stood to draw, the binocular fell from his lap and clanked like a brick. The once-in-a-lifetime behemoth bolted before the binocular hit the ground.

The Lesson: Practice in all the gear you might wear hunting to avoid mishaps at the moment of truth. Murphy's Law works overtime when the pressure is on. So immediately after getting situated in your stand, perform a systems test. Draw your bow, make sure your treestand doesn't squeak, check that your sleeve isn't in the way of the string, etc. Do this before you see the big buck of your dreams – or else it may live eternally in your nightmares.


Mr. No-Whitetail

Despite using a bipod, the Thompson/Center's barrel quivered like a mesquite tree in the South Texas wind. Larry Weishuhn was in the midst of a bout of buck fever, and he knew it. Sure, the whitetail before him was the king of all 6-points, but it was still a 6-point.


He'd taken hundreds of bigger deer. Maybe it was the anticipation formed by talking about this very cull buck over the last several years. Whatever – Larry fired only to see a puff of dust strike halfway between him and the now-startled deer. It remains one of the worst shots "Mr. Whitetail" has made in 50 years of hunting.

The Lesson: "If you're stricken with buck fever," said Larry, "take a deep breath and focus on a specific spot on the animal's vital zone, not the animal as a whole. And if you can't get it together, don't shoot until you can." Of course, this sounds simple – until adrenaline seizes your ability to think clearly. That's why many veteran bowhunters place a sticker with the words "Pick a Spot" on their bow's limb. Larry should have placed that sticker on his rifle.

The Bone Protector

Michael Waddell is rich and famous not just due to his snappy one-liners, but also because he's an uncanny big buck hunter who thrives under pressure – usually. Then there was the time a 150-inch 8-point he'd been hunting for days finally swaggered directly to his tree and turned broadside at six paces.

With the cameras rolling and the hunt on the line, Michael released his arrow and missed the entire animal.


The Lesson: "Aim," said Waddell. Just because an animal is spit-swapping close doesn't mean you can point and fire. And just because the Bone Collector misses a buck on camera at six yards doesn't mean you can laugh at him. Well – yes, it does.

Big bucks are sneaky. Always hang your bow in front of you and practice shooting from different angles.

Carney's Whitetail Hell

Mike Carney is the executive vice president of the company that publishes this magazine and a serious whitetail hunter. One day, he was perched on a steep hillside in his Illinois woods, overlooking a well-worn trail. He was hunting a 170-plus-inch buck he'd seen earlier in the season. Now it stood mere feet behind him, but there was nothing he could do.


Instead of walking up the trail as Carney had prepared for, the bruiser busted through the wall of brush behind him. Carney couldn't rotate, stand, or even reach for his bow as it hung on the tree's trunk near his left shoulder. Meanwhile, sensing something was up, the big buck froze. After four minutes of pure agony for the quivering hunter, the buck turned and walked away. Carney nearly cried.

The Lesson: Bucks don't get big by blundering down doe trails. They're sneaky. So always anticipate the unanticipated. Hang your bow near your bow hand in front of you so you can reach it with one subtle hand movement. Practice shooting your rifle or bow from sitting positions and weird angles. This is one of the best remedies for runaway bucks.

Big Shot No Shot

Darren LaSorte is the NRA's former hunting policy manager. He's also a guy who deems himself naturally unlucky and laments that he's never killed a B&C whitetail despite vigorous effort. But last year, during the muzzleloader season, his luck almost turned. Almost. In an act he later called "selfless," he decided to exit his stand at noon because his hunting buddy needed some help cooking breakfast.

Just then, however, a fat doe appeared. Figuring he could serve his hungry girlfriend and the landowner in one aim of his CVA, he fired. Then the doe did the only thing that LaSorte says could have caused the following blunder: It died directly in front of him. Knowing it was dead and considering he was about to climb down from his stand, LaSorte saw little reason to reload before lowering his rifle to the ground. And you know what happened next.

"This @#&! Booner buck runs right past me," said LaSorte. "I pulled my rifle back up but couldn't reload it in time." And now no amount of time can ease his pain.

The Lesson: Always keep your gun or bow loaded and ready during legal hunting times, no matter how improbable you'll use it. This includes walking to and from your truck and outhouse. Darren should have reloaded his rifle immediately, then simply removed the primer when lowering it. Or he could have refrained from shooting the doe from his best stand in the first place.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Best Whitetail Shot Placement with a Rifle

Best Whitetail Shot Placement with a Rifle

Craig Boddington breaks down where hunters should aim on a whitetail that provides the best possible margin for error.

Venison Cheeseburger Bites Recipe

Venison Cheeseburger Bites Recipe

If you're tired of the same old jalapeno and cream cheese poppers, here's a completely different take on the popular party appetizer. Easy to make, and incredibly delicious, these mini cheeseburgers, wrapped in bacon, make the perfect one-bite-fits-all snack for your next tailgate party or hunting camp.

B&C Typical Mule Deer

B&C Typical Mule Deer

Doug Burris Jr's typical mule deer taken in 1969, could just be one record that will never be broken.

Hunting Coues Deer South of the Border

Hunting Coues Deer South of the Border

Former Delta Force Operator Kyle Lamb hikes the rugged desert mountains of northern Sonora in pursuit of the diminutive Coues species of whitetail.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Are predators really to blame for declining deer numbers? The answer might surprise you.Do Coyotes Really Affect the Whitetail Herd? Conservation

Do Coyotes Really Affect the Whitetail Herd?

Jeff Johnston

Are predators really to blame for declining deer numbers? The answer might surprise you.

Learn how to grill the perfect medium-rare venison steak with these tips and tricks.Venison Grilling Tips Recipes

Venison Grilling Tips

Jenny Nguyen-Wheatley

Learn how to grill the perfect medium-rare venison steak with these tips and tricks.

These are our favorite new products of the year for the archery crowd.Best New Bowhunting Gear for 2020 Bowhunting

Best New Bowhunting Gear for 2020

Petersen's Hunting Editors - May 21, 2020

These are our favorite new products of the year for the archery crowd.

Mossberg's accurate Patriot Predator is the most affordable way to harness the power of the 6.5 PRC.Mossberg Patriot Predator 6.5 PRC: Rifle Review Guns

Mossberg Patriot Predator 6.5 PRC: Rifle Review

Brad Fitzpatrick - June 26, 2020

Mossberg's accurate Patriot Predator is the most affordable way to harness the power of the...

See More Trending Articles

More Whitetail

We're deciphering new deer data for rut success.Daylight Deer Movement During the Rut Whitetail

Daylight Deer Movement During the Rut

Jeff Johnston

We're deciphering new deer data for rut success.

Killing a smart old bruiser is a lifelong endeavor for most of us.Tips for Hunting Mature Whitetails Whitetail

Tips for Hunting Mature Whitetails

Craig Boddington

Killing a smart old bruiser is a lifelong endeavor for most of us.

Western Oklahoma was the site for big deer and top-notch gear from Savage and Mossy Oak.Cowboy Up for Canadian River Whitetails Whitetail

Cowboy Up for Canadian River Whitetails

Darren LaSorte

Western Oklahoma was the site for big deer and top-notch gear from Savage and Mossy Oak.

New to the world of whitetail hunting? No problem! Give these tips a try.5 Tips For New Deer Hunters Whitetail

5 Tips For New Deer Hunters

Jace Bauserman

New to the world of whitetail hunting? No problem! Give these tips a try.

See More Whitetail

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save.

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Petersen's Hunting App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Petersen's Hunting subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now